Appeal 2007-1271
Application 10/005,583
Issue 3:
3. We decide the question of whether Kuwata discloses uploading a
control screen to a user browser.
a. Appellant argues that Kuwata does not disclose uploading
content to a user browser in the form of at least one control screen
(Br. 12).
b. The Examiner disagrees. The Examiner argues that Kuwata
discloses different folders shown to users based upon their
registration. The Examiner notes that for registered users, the
“Public” and “private” folders are shown, while for an Administrator
the “DEPARTMENT” folder is shown in addition to the Public and
private folders (see Kuwata, ¶ 0047). Therefore, the Examiner finds
Kuwata discloses content that is uploaded based on user registration
before the scanning occurred (Answer 14).
With respect to issue 3, we agree with Appellant that Kuwata does not
disclose uploading content to a user browser in the form of at least one
control screen. While we agree with the Examiner that user registration or
Administrator status permits various levels of access, we find nothing in the
cited portion of Kuwata that may be reasonably characterized as an express
or inherent teaching of uploading a control screen to a user browser. Our
further review of the entire Kuwata reference finds no disclosure to support
the Examiner’s position.
Issue 4:
4. We decide the question of whether Kuwata discloses uploading an
application to a user browser.
9
Page: Previous 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 Next
Last modified: September 9, 2013