Ex Parte Murphy et al - Page 4



               Appeal 2007-1378                                                                          
               Application 10/327,459                                                                    
           1         The second issue is whether appellants have sustained their burden of               
           2   showing that the Examiner erred in rejecting the claims on appeal as being                
           3   unpatentable under 35 U.S.C. § 103(a) over Singer and Curatolo.                           
           4                                                                                             
           5         D.  Findings of fact                                                                
           6         The following findings of fact are believed to be supported by a                    
           7   preponderance of the evidence.  To the extent that a finding of fact is a                 
           8   conclusion of law, it may be treated as such.  Additional findings as                     
           9   necessary may appear in the Discussion portion of the opinion.                            
         10                                                                                              
         11                                  The invention                                               
         12          The invention relates to a dry blend of non-dihydrate azithromycin                  
         13    which can be used to make tablets containing the azithromycin.                            
         14    Specification, page 3:11-14.                                                              
         15          “Dry blend” means a generally homogeneous mixture of two or more                    
         16    materials in particle form.  Specification, page 4:34-36.                                 
         17          “Non-dihydrate azithromycin” means all amorphous and crystalline                    
         18    forms of azithromycin, other than the dihydrate form of azithromycin                      
         19    (Form A).  Specification, page 5:15-19.                                                   
         20          According to appellants, flow properties of a formulation may be                    
         21    evaluated by a number of methods known in the art.  Specification,                        
         22    page 13:6-7.                                                                              
         23          One way of characterizing formulation properties of a powdered                      
         24    material is by bulk density measurements.  Specification, page 13:7-9.                    



                                                   4                                                     

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013