Ex Parte Murphy et al - Page 7



               Appeal 2007-1378                                                                          
               Application 10/327,459                                                                    
           1                                    Curatolo                                                 
           2         Curatolo tells us that azithromycin is a broad spectrum antimicrobial               
           3   compound.  Col. 1:11-13.                                                                  
           4         Curatolo, which predates Singer, describes an oral dosage form of                   
           5   azithromycin.  Col. 2:36-37.                                                              
           6         Excipients and lubricants may be combined with azithromycin.  Col.                  
           7   6:54-57.                                                                                  
           8         Curatolo, which is said to be owned by appellants’ assignee Pfizer                  
           9   Inc., tells one the following about the level of skill in the art more than one           
         10    year prior to the filing date of the application on appeal:                               
         11                      As known in the art, tablet blends may be dry-granulated                
         12                or wet granulated before tableting.  Alternatively, tablet blends             
         13                may be directly compressed.  The choice of processing                         
         14                approach depends upon the properties of the drug and chosen                   
         15                excipients, for example particle size, blending compatibility,                
         16                density and flowability.  For azithromycin tablets, granulation               
         17                is preferred, with wet granulation being most preferred.                      
         18                Azithromycin may be wet-granulated, and then other excipients                 
         19                may be added extragranularly.  Alternatively, azithromycin and                
         20                one or more excipients may be wet-granulated.                                 
         21                                                                                              
         22    Col. 7:51-61.                                                                             
         23                                                                                              
         24    Curatolo confirms that granulation was a known technique for use in                       
         25    the overall process of making azithromycin tablets.                                       
         26          Curatolo further confirms that the choice of processing approach                    
         27    depends on the properties sought to be obtained.                                          




                                                   7                                                     

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013