Ex Parte Seul - Page 14

                  Appeal 2007-1624                                                                                         
                  Application 10/424,662                                                                                   
                  33.  The particles described by Drmanac are subjected to “fixations” (FF 20)                             
                  on the substrate and the resulting hybridization areas can be “reused as                                 
                  classic filters” (FF 21, 22), indicating that the particles are “permanently                             
                  anchored” by chemical bonding to the substrate on which the monolayer                                    
                  rests, as required by claims 76, 106, and 107, and also on the substrate                                 
                  surface as recited in claim 86.                                                                          
                  34.  Drmanac describes all elements of claims 76 and 86 (FF 29-33).                                      
                  35.  The DNA attached to Drmanac’s particles can be derived from a                                       
                  genomic library of random clones (FF 18) or corresponding oligonucleotides                               
                  (FF 17) and thus are “compositionally random” as recited in claims 77 and                                
                  108.                                                                                                     
                  36.  The hybridization areas can be divided into submatrices on a single                                 
                  hybridization area in which the submatrices comprise different targets (FF                               
                  28; Drmanac, col. 11, l. 58 to col. 20, l. 1).  Thus, the particles are arranged                         
                  in definite locations on certain parts of the substrate, but not others, and thus                        
                  are “spatially non-random” as recited in claim 77.                                                       
                  37.  The monolayer particle array of Drmanac is in contact with a solution at                            
                  least during hybridization and washing (FF 26) which meets the claim 77                                  
                  limitation of “a contiguous aliquot of solution” that is “placed on said planar                          
                  configuration” of the array.                                                                             
                  38.  Drmanac describes all elements of claim 77 (FF 29, 30, 32, and 35-37).                              
                  39.  The target DNA is denatured to form single-stranded DNA and                                         
                  hybridized to complementary genomic DNAs or oligonucleotides which are                                   
                  attached to the particles (FF 27) as required by claims 78 and 79.                                       
                  40.  The DNA attached to the particles can be “derived from a human being”                               
                  (FF 16) as recited in claims 80 and 81.                                                                  

                                                            14                                                             

Page:  Previous  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013