Ex Parte Adoline et al - Page 7



           Appeal 2007-1793                                                                        
           Application 10/911,196                                                                  
                 8. As such, Hubweber’s locking arrangement is at least partially secured,         
                       via collar 12, to the housing (cylinder 1).                                 
                 9. Hubweber’s locking arrangement includes a locking sleeve (the one-             
                       piece collet 7 and wall 4) having an upper section (wall 4) and a lower     
                       section (collet 7) (Hubweber, col. 2, ll. 22-23), and contains parts in     
                       addition to the locking sleeve, viz, collar 12 and spring 9.                
                 10. Hubweber discloses gas pressure below piston 3 to bias piston rod 2           
                       outwardly of cylinder 1 (Hubweber, col. 1, ll. 57-61)                       
                 11. As such, Hubweber discloses a spring extending between the guide              
                       member (piston 3) and the bottom end of the housing (lower, closed          
                       end of cylinder 1).                                                         
                 12. Gottling describes “a piston rod connected to a working piston”               
                       (Gottling, col. 1, ll. 14-15).                                              
                 13. Gottling does not state where the piston is located and does not show         
                       the piston positioned in an internal chamber of the housing.                
                 14. Gottling discloses a braking apparatus 10 comprising a housing 12 of          
                       a working cylinder 14 (Gottling, col. 2, ll. 54-56).                        
                 15. As shown in Figure 1, the housing 12 is closed on one end (shown on           
                       the right side of Figure 1), and the piston rod 20 extends through this     
                       closed end of the housing.                                                  
                 16. If the piston is attached to the end of piston rod 20 that extends            
                       through the closed end of housing 12, then the piston would be              
                       positioned outside of the internal chamber of the housing.                  

                                                7                                                  



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013