Ex Parte Hensbergen et al - Page 6



                 Appeal 2007-1978                                                                                       
                 Application 10/185,702                                                                                 


                 invention unpatentable under 35 U.S.C. § 103(a)?  Particularly, do these                               
                 combined disclosures render the claimed invention unpatentable given that                              
                 they teach storing transmitted messages in a queue?                                                    

                                               FINDINGS OF FACT                                                         
                        The following findings of fact are supported by a preponderance of                              
                 the evidence.                                                                                          
                                                       The Invention                                                    
                        1.  Appellants invented a method and system for transmitting data                               
                 in a switched network between a client and a server using an Ethernet                                  
                 protocol4 in lieu of TCP/IP to route the data.  (Title, abstract.)                                     
                        2. Upon receiving a client’s request5 to read or access data in a                               
                 designated storage device, the server reads and accesses the data through one                          
                 read request when the requested data is stored in contiguous sectors of the                            
                 storage device.6  (Specification 15.)                                                                  


                                                                                                                       
                 4 The protocol is based on fixed-size linear arrays of sectors.  All protocol                          
                 parameters are in terms of sectors.  Request and Response payload data are                             
                 clustered in blocks of contiguous sectors of 512 bytes.  (Specification 12.)                           
                 5 Length field 616 is used to indicate the length of the request or response in                        
                 sectors and sector identifier field 618 identifies the first sector.                                   
                 (Specification 14.)                                                                                    
                 6 The response maintains the values in the request and fills in the device size                        
                 in sectors per request in the length field 616 and the initial request window                          
                 size in the flow control field 614. (Id.)                                                              
                                                           6                                                            



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013