Ex Parte 5694604 et al - Page 119


                Appeal 2007-2127                                                                                  
                Reexamination Control No. 90/006,621                                                              
                       methods of lexical and syntactic analysis and the mode of operation of                     
                       the present invention are substantially the same for both natural and                      
                       formal languages.  Spreadsheet and database entries are also generally                     
                       entered in ASCII code or the equivalent binary code.  For purposes of                      
                       illustration of the structure and operation of the present invention the                   
                       disclosed embodiment is shown and described herein as a processor of                       
                       a formal language; that is, a compiler of a programming language.                          
                       However, it will be understood that substantially the same structure,                      
                       operation, and lexical and syntactic analyses may be employed to                           
                       process the code of a natural language, such as, for example, by                           
                       utilizing lexical analysis to determine correct spelling and/or syntactic                  
                       analysis to determine correct grammar of the natural language code                         
                       being entered by an editor or word processor, or to process the code of                    
                       a spreadsheet or database.                                                                 
                5.     The 1990 application also added disclosure not found in the 1982 and                       
                1985 applications that stated (now at '603 patent, col. 3, lines 48-61):                          
                              It will be obvious to those skilled in the computer arts that the                   
                       same or equivalent hardware and software may be employed to                                
                       perform lexical and syntactic analysis of natural language code, or to                     
                       calculate the numeric code of a spreadsheet, concurrently in real time                     
                       as the user enters or edits such code at the keyboard.                                     
                6.     The added disclosures in the 1990 application were omitted from the                        
                1994 application, as filed, and in the issued '604 patent.                                        
                7.     The '604 patent states that it is a continuation of the 1990 application,                  
                which is said to be a continuation of the 1985 and 1982 applications                              
                (col. 1, lines 6-15).                                                                             
                8.     The '604 patent does not incorporate the 1990, 1885, or 1982                               
                applications by reference.                                                                        




                                                       119                                                        

Page:  Previous  112  113  114  115  116  117  118  119  120  121  122  123  124  125  126  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013