Ex Parte Graff - Page 2

                Appeal 2007-2206                                                                                   
                Application 10/181,977                                                                             

                example made of crêped cellulose wadding, also called tissue paper, with a                         
                grammage of between 12 and 30 g/m2, endowed with protuberances which                               
                are obtained by embossing” (Specification 1).  Embossing the paper is                              
                desirable because it “gives fullness to the sheet and it leads to improved                         
                liquid absorption, touch and softness” (id.).                                                      
                       The Specification discloses “an improved design of an embossed                              
                sheet comprising at least one ply with a background pattern having                                 
                microprotuberances and especially, but not only, making it possible to                             
                combine it with a pattern having macroprotuberances” (id. at 4).  The                              
                Specification discloses that using microprotuberances as the background                            
                pattern “improve[s] the final appearance of the sheet by better highlighting                       
                the pattern having macroprotuberances . . .” (id.).                                                
                                                 DISCUSSION                                                        
                1.  CLAIMS                                                                                         
                       Claims 1, 3-10, 23, and 24 are on appeal.  Claims 12-22 are also                            
                pending but have been withdrawn from consideration by the Examiner.                                
                Claim 1 is representative and reads as follows:                                                    
                              1.  An embossed sheet comprising at least one ply of                                 
                       creped cellulose wadding with a basis weight of between 12                                  
                       and 30 g/m2 having an embossed pattern comprising at least a                                
                       first series of protuberances formed so as to project from one                              
                       face of the ply and the density of which is greater than 20                                 
                       protuberances per cm2, characterized in that each protuberance                              
                       of the first series comprises a truncated polyhedron-shaped base                            
                       and a flattened free-end portion with rounded edges.                                        

                       Thus, claim 1 is directed to a sheet that has an embossed pattern                           
                comprising more than twenty protuberances per square centimeter.  Each                             

                                                        2                                                          

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013