Ex Parte 6440359 et al - Page 14

                 Appeal  2007-2359                                                                                       
                 Application 90/006,951                                                                                  
                                Si   0.60–0.90   0.35–0.60                                                               
                                Mn   up to 0.35   0.02–0.15                                                              
                                Fe   up to 0.35  up to 0.35                                                              
                                Cu   up to 0.05  up to 0.10                                                              
                 70. The extent of "overlap" between the EP/WO disclosure and                                            
                 the 359 patent claimed subject matter can also be seen in Figure 1 of                                   
                 the 359 patent.                                                                                         
                                  {Figure 1 of the 359 patent is shown below:}10                                         











                  {Figure 1 is said to compare the composition of the invented alloy with the                            
                                                       prior art}                                                        
                 71. Region A is said to be the broad range of alloy compositions, while                                 
                 region B is said to be the narrow (preferred) range of alloy compositions.                              
                 (359 patent at 2:1–6.)                                                                                  

                                                                                                                        
                 10 The text in curly braces preceding and following the Figures are provided                            
                 to ensure compliance with section 508 of the U.S. Rehabilitation Act for                                
                 publication of this Decision on the USPTO website pursuant to the Freedom                               
                 of Information Act.  They are not part of the Decision.                                                 

                                                           14                                                            

Page:  Previous  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013