Ex Parte Skoufis - Page 4

                Appeal  2007-2364                                                                                
                Application 09/879,613                                                                           
                11. The Specification does not describe any working examples of the                              
                invention or of the prior art.                                                                   
                12. Claim 9 on appeal reads:                                                                     
                       A packaged PVA sponge for use in clean rooms,                                             
                       said cleaning article having particulate, metal ion and anionic                           
                       counts at or below the values specified for a clean room,                                 
                       said package comprising a sealed flexible plastic bag,                                    
                       said sponge being positioned in said bag, and containing a                                
                       quantity of de-ionized water,                                                             
                             said de-ionized water containing hydrogen peroxide in a                             
                             concentration effective to kill and retard the growth of                            
                             bacteria in said sponge, said amount being low enough to                            
                             substantially ensure decomposition of said hydrogen                                 
                             peroxide in a relatively short period of time after the                             
                             container is sealed and being between 0.05 and 0.5% by                              
                             volume.                                                                             
                13. Independent claims 1 and 5 are similar, being drawn to methods of                            
                packaging the PVA sponge; but they do not recited the particle, metal ion                        
                and anionic count limitations, and the end points of the range of hydrogen                       
                peroxide concentration are recited to be "around" or "about" 0.05 and                            
                0.5% by volume.                                                                                  
                14. Dependent claims 4 and 12 recite that the "volume" and the                                   
                concentration by volume, respectively, of hydrogen peroxide is                                   
                around 0.1%.                                                                                     







                                                       4                                                         

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013