Appeal 2007-2370 Application 09/373,141 1 Claim 63 rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 103(a) as unpatentable over Shkedy, 2 eCommerce, and the Appellant's admitted prior art. 3 Claim 63 is as follows: 4 A computer-implemented auction system for negotiating discount 5 credits between sellers offering at least one pre-defined category of 6 goods or service items and buyers wishing to purchase goods or 7 service items selected from said category, 8 comprising: 9 an auction system having an auction engine that presents a first 10 interface for access by buyers in communicating willingness to 11 purchase items selected from a pre-defined category at a negotiated 12 category discount and a second interface for access by sellers in 13 communicating willingness to offer items selected from the pre- 14 defined category; 15 the first interface including a commitment amount field through which 16 each buyer communicates the amount that buyer will commit to spend 17 and a requested discount field through which each buyer 18 communicates the smallest discount that buyer will accept; 19 a data storage associated with the auction engine for storing the 20 identity of buyers who have communicated willingness to purchase 21 items from the pre-defined category, and for storing bid data 22 indicative of the commitment amount and requested discount 23 communicated by each buyer; 24 the auction system further having a compilation system that analyzes 25 the bid data to present information to sellers through the second 26 interface indicative of the aggregate commitment amounts associated 27 with different requested discounts; 28 the second interface having a discount offer field through which each 29 seller communicates the discount that seller is willing to offer; 30 a commitment system having a mechanism for terminating 31 negotiation in response to a pre-defined criterion and for identifying a 32 selected seller that has offered the greatest discount during the 33 negotiation; 14Page: Previous 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 Next
Last modified: September 9, 2013