Ex Parte Werthman et al - Page 7



              Appeal 2007-2537                                                                     
              Application 11/170,468                                                               
          1         15.  Weibe describes affixing temperature indicating decals on                 
          2   electronic components, which illuminate when a temperature level is                  
          3   exceeded (Weibe 2:6-16).                                                             
          4         Ko                                                                             
          5         16.  The Examiner found that Ko describes using temperature                    
          6   sensitive labels to indicate excessive heat (Id).                                    
          7         17.  The Examiner also found that Ko describes using multiple                  
          8   indicators (Id.).                                                                    
          9         18.  Ko describes a plurality of warning strips (Fig. 2 items 31, 32, 33)      
         10   placed on a PVC power cord for indicating when a predetermined                       
         11   temperature of the cord has been exceeded (Ko 2:10-32).                              
         12         19.  Ko describes that its invention is related to a warning device            
         13   capable of detecting overload or overheat for electric cords, cables, or             
         14   sockets (Ko 1:8-11).                                                                 
         15         The Examiner’s reasoning for combining the references                          
         16         20.  The Examiner found that one skilled in the art would have used a          
         17   temperature indicator as taught by the APA, Laske, Weibe or Ko on the                
         18   Connor structure, so as to warn a person that a temperature of the connector         
         19   had risen to an undesirable temperature (Final Rejection 4 and Answer 4).            
         20         21.  With respect to claims 3, 11, 13-18 and 21, the Examiner                  
         21   concluded that it would have been obvious to locate the temperature                  
         22   indicator on the compressible section of the connector, since one of ordinary        



                                                7                                                  



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013