Ex Parte Confalone et al - Page 6



               Appeal 2007-4259                                                                            
               Application 10/417,752                                                                      
               free formaldehyde while maintaining acceptable wet and dry tensile                          
               properties” (Iacoviello, col. 2, ll. 23-26).                                                
                      DeWitt discloses the print bonding of a non-woven web with a binder                  
               that contains an opacifying agent.  DeWitt discloses the visual pattern                     
               printed on the non-woven web is enhanced by the addition of an opacifying                   
               agent (DeWitt, col. 5, ll. 19-22).                                                          
                      Like Iacoviello, DeWitt recognized that it was desirable to avoid                    
               components which give rise to formaldehyde (DeWitt, col. 4, ll. 15-18).                     
               This recognition does not indicate that an opacifying agent would not                       
               function in a binder that comprises some amount of N-methylol acrylamide.                   
                      Gorley discloses a premoistened non-woven wipe that incorporates an                  
               opacifying agent to increase its opacity and teaches that the binder contains               
               the opacifying agents.  (Gorley 2-3)                                                        
                      Thus, the present record reveals that a person of ordinary skill in the              
               art would have recognized the need to produce compositions that have                        
               reduced formaldehyde.  A person of ordinary skill in the art would have                     
               recognized the suitability of utilizing opacifying agents in binding                        
               compositions for nonwoven fibers.  A person of ordinary skill in the art                    
               would have reasonably expected that the incorporation of an opacifying                      
               agent in the binder composition of Iacoviello would have produced                           
               nonwoven materials that had increased opacity.                                              




                                                    6                                                      



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013