Thomas E. and Joan A. Bennett - Page 24

                                       - 24 -                                         
          pellets or the recycler.  Bennett testified that he was motivated           
          by the report of Stanley M. Ulanoff (Ulanoff), a marketer, which            
          was attached to the offering circular, even though Ulanoff had              
          not done a marketing analysis or put a value on the machine.  He            
          also testified that in his experience, the price of machinery is            
          generally predicated upon the performance aspects rather than the           
          production cost.  However, such an analysis was not done by                 
          Ulanoff.  Black testified that he "relied on others" regarding              
          the evaluation of the recycler, but that it was "in hindsight,              
          not very brilliant on [his] part" to have done so.  It is                   
          questionable from the records in these cases how closely                    
          petitioners read the offering memorandum and to what extent they            
          relied on the representations therein.  However, even if                    
          petitioners did thoroughly review the offering memorandum, such             
          reading does not relieve them of negligence.                                
               On its face, the Empire transaction should have raised                 
          serious questions in the minds of ordinarily prudent investors.             
          According to the offering memorandum, the projected benefits for            
          each $50,000 investor were investment tax credits in 1981 of                
          $86,328 plus deductions in 1981 of $39,399.  In the first year of           
          the investment alone, petitioners each claimed an operating loss            
          in the amount of $20,510 and investment tax and business energy             
          credits related to Empire totaling $42,402, while petitioners               








Page:  Previous  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011