Estate of Willis Edward Clack, Deceased, Marshall & Ilsley Trust Company, Co-Personal Representative, and Richard E. Clack, Co-Personal Representative - Page 43

                                       - 43 -                                         
          the proper date for determining whether the surviving spouse has            
          a qualifying income interest for life in the property.                      
               I agree that the election under section 2056(b)(7)(B)(v),              
          like any other election that an executor makes under the estate             
          tax provisions, must be made after the date of death of the                 
          decedent.  However, I think the election can be made only as to             
          an otherwise qualifying income interest in the property and that            
          the election itself cannot qualify otherwise nonqualifying                  
          property.  The definition of an interest in property in section             
          2056(b)(7)(B)(iii), the definition of a specific portion of                 
          property in section 2056(b)(7)(B)(iv), and the phrase "any                  
          property" in the definition of an election in section                       
          2056(b)(7)(B)(v) do not change that result.  Whatever the nature            
          of the property, whatever the interest in the property, or                  
          whatever the specific portion of the property, the statute                  
          requires the surviving spouse to have a "qualifying income                  
          interest for life" in that "property".                                      



          (...continued)                                                              
          8 months after husband and her income interest in husband's                 
          estate is the only property in which she has any interest.  If              
          the executor of husband's estate files the estate tax return                
          before wife dies and elects on the return to treat one-half of              
          the property as QTIP, husband's estate will get a marital                   
          deduction for $600,000 leaving $600,000 in his estate.  Wife's              
          estate will include the $600,000 QTIP property.  Neither estate             
          will be subject to tax (sheltered by husband's and wife's                   
          respective unified credit).  If, on the other hand, husband's               
          executor does not file the estate tax return until after wife's             
          death, no QTIP election may be made, $600,000 of husband's estate           
          is taxable, and wife's unified credit is wasted.                            



Page:  Previous  33  34  35  36  37  38  39  40  41  42  43  44  45  46  47  48  49  50  51  52  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011