Alfred P. Duffy - Page 8

                                   - NEXTRECORD  -                                    
          debt when she participated in the strike and that the penalty               
          withheld from her wages extinguished such debt.                             
               We think that petitioner's circumstances are different from            
          those of the taxpayer in Tucker v. Commissioner, supra.  In the             
          latter case, the taxpayer did not dispute the fact that she had             
          violated State law and incurred a debt as a result of such                  
          violation.  Nor did the taxpayer dispute the fact that the                  
          withholding of the penalty from her wages satisfied such debt.              
          In the present case, however, petitioner vigorously disputed the            
          auditor's determination that he was liable to the school district           
          for excess advances, and the parties' dispute was not resolved by           
          the New York courts by the end of 1990.                                     
               Similarly, respondent's reliance on Kuntz v. Commissioner,             
          supra, and Kasey v. Commissioner, supra, is also misplaced.  In             
          those cases, we held that the taxpayers constructively received             
          income to which they were entitled but which was garnished and              
          remitted to judgment creditors.  In neither case is there any               
          indication that the taxpayers disputed their liability.  Thus,              
          these cases are also distinguishable from the present one.                  
               In view of the foregoing, we hold that petitioner is not               
          taxable, in 1990, on the net wages withheld by the school                   
          district during that year.  Because 1990 is the only year before            
          us, we need not, and do not, decide whether the net wages are               
          taxable in some other year.                                                 
          Issue (2): Section 72(t)                                                    




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011