American Stores Company and Subsidiaries - Page 34

                                       - 34 -                                         
          do so under section 404(a)(6), anticipated contributions for the            
          corresponding plan year would become indeterminate and,                     
          therefore, unreliable.  They would no longer approximate the                
          amount of actual contributions for a plan year.  This, in turn,             
          would cause the section 413(b)(7) fiction to become unworkable,             
          leading to the inability of a plan to prospectively determine               
          whether the overall limit would be exceeded.                                
               Petitioner attempts to finesse this point by positing that,            
          whereas section 404(a)(6) deems a contribution to be made in an             
          earlier tax year, section 413(b)(7) measures employer                       
          contributions that are expected to be actually made to a                    
          Multiemployer Plan during its plan year.  Under this reasoning,             
          the treatment of contributions pursuant to section 404(a)(6) does           
          not affect the limits under section 413(b)(7).  Petitioner                  
          asserts that section 404(a)(6) "expressly limits this deemed                
          treatment" of grace period contributions in the preceding tax               
          year to section 404(a).  Petitioner then concludes that the tax             
          year in which a contribution is deducted is "wholly irrelevant"             
          under section 413(b)(7).                                                    
               We disagree with the preceding disjunctive analysis.                   
          Petitioner ignores that section 413(b)(7) is merely an amplifying           
          refinement of section 404(a) in the context of CBA Plans.  See              
          Lucky Stores, Inc., & Subs. v. Commissioner, 107 T.C. at 11.                








Page:  Previous  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  35  36  37  38  39  40  41  42  43  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011