H & A International Jewelry, Ltd. - Page 10

                                        -   -10                                           
          compensation for the 10 companies by percentage of sales:  Upper            
          quartile, 3.2 percent; median, 2.1 percent; and lower quartile,             
          1.0 percent.6  Respondent allowed compensation of 3.2 percent of            
          net sales.                                                                  
               Petitioner contends that due to Mr. Haviv's talents and                
          market positioning, petitioner has no true competitors in the               
          United States.  Therefore, petitioner presents what it considers            
          "the only person remotely qualified within 100 miles of Atlanta"            
          as a "competitor."  He has been designated as Mr. W for this                
          trial.  Mr. W owns 100 percent of the stock of what have been               
          designated as B Co. and C Co., each a retail jewelry store in a             
          city in the southeast region of the United States.  At the end of           
          the companies' fiscal year 1991, C Co was merged into B Co.                 
               Mr. W has been in the jewelry business for 57 years and has            
          operated C Co. and B Co. for 52 and 36 years respectively.  B Co.           
          and C Co. have customers in Atlanta and have competed against               
          petitioner on a few occasions in the sale of large diamonds and             
          precious stones.                                                            
               In 1991, there was an industrywide recession induced by the            
          10 percent luxury tax on jewelry.  See Omnibus Budget                       
          Reconciliation Act of 1990, Pub. L. 101-508, sec. 11221(a), 104             
          Stat. 1388, 1388-441 to 1388-442.                                           


          6         For example, 25 percent (in this survey 2) of the                 
          companies compensated their officers greater than 3.2 percent of            
          annual sales.                                                               




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011