CGF Industries, Inc. and Subsidiaries - Page 39




                                       - 39 -                                         

          transactions.  Rather, they represented very important steps in             
          the series.  Absent the initial step of distributing funds to the           
          Family Trusts, the remaining steps of forming the CGF and Lincoln           
          Partnerships, and of petitioners' acquiring the term interests              
          and the Family Trusts' acquiring the remainders, could not have             
          been successfully accomplished.  Indeed, the creation of these              
          partnerships was necessary to achieve petitioners' intended end             
          result, which was to funnel large amounts of money outside of               
          petitioners' corporate structure and into the hands of their                
          shareholders while enjoying favorable tax treatment.  The                   
          intention to bring about this end result is manifested in                   
          Robert A. Page's letters and in the minutes of petitioners' board           
          meetings.  On the basis of the stipulated factual record, we                
          conclude that, in spite of the form in which the joint investment           
          transaction was cast, its substance shows petitioners acquiring             
          partnership interests B in their entirety and then carving out              
          remainder interests for the benefit of the Family Trusts.                   
               It bears noting that, in his letter of May 15, 1986,                   
          Mr. Page wrote of a potential pitfall which could thwart the                
          success of his plan; i.e., where the term interest holder funds             
          the remaindermen with the amounts necessary to obtain their                 
          interests.  In that situation, he warned, petitioners would be              
          viewed as acquiring the entire interest and then transferring the           
          remainders to their shareholders, in which case the otherwise               
          favorable tax results stemming from the amortization deductions             
          would disappear.  Mr. Page's solution to this "limiting factor,"            

Page:  Previous  29  30  31  32  33  34  35  36  37  38  39  40  41  42  43  44  45  46  47  48  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011