Estate of Lucille M. Horstmeier, deceased, Mary E. Scott, Executor - Page 15




                                        - 15 -                                         
               Also problematic for Ms. Scott’s characterization of the                
          arrangement regarding the Glenview house are certain subsequent              
          events.  In 1979, approximately 4 years after the Glenview house             
          was purchased, Ms. Scott and Ms. Horstmeier purchased land in                
          Wisconsin.  The property was titled jointly in both names.  This             
          casts some doubt on the rationale offered for avoiding a joint               
          title for the Glenview house, although concededly Ms. Horstmeier             
          may have been less concerned about appearances in another State.             
          In addition, according to her testimony, because Ms. Scott made              
          all of the payments on the Wisconsin property, Ms. Horstmeier                
          suggested when all payments had been made that the title be                  
          placed solely in Ms. Scott’s name.  This was done.  This episode             
          at least suggests that Ms. Horstmeier and Ms. Scott were prepared            
          in some circumstances to adjust the legal title to property to               
          reflect their perceptions of the underlying equities of                      
          ownership.                                                                   
               Much later, starting in the late 1980’s, Ms. Horstmeier took            
          out a second mortgage on the Glenview house to secure a credit               
          line and borrowed against it to provide funds to the business                
          college she co-owned, which was experiencing financial                       
          difficulties.  Ms. Scott testified that she was strongly opposed             
          to the use of the house to secure debt to benefit the college.               
          This exercise of exclusive control by Ms. Horstmeier casts some              








Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011