Plains Petroleum Company and Subsidiaries - Page 63




                                       - 63 -                                         

          $9.75 million, if not more.  Consequently, we conclude that                 
          petitioner did not pay more for Tri-Power than its assets were              
          worth.                                                                      
               Additionally, we note that petitioner's acquisition of Tri-            
          Power was competitive with other acquisitions that took place               
          during the fourth quarter of 1986.  Petitioner paid $4.64/BOE               
          ($9.75 million � 2.1 million BOE) to acquire the Tri-Power                  
          reserves.  Accordingly, the price per BOE paid by petitioner for            
          the Tri-Power reserves was below the fourth quarter 1986 median             
          of $6.45/BOE reported by Strevig in its 1986 fourth quarter                 
          report and below the revised fourth quarter 1986 median of                  
          $5.18/BOE reported by Strevig during February 1992.  Accordingly,           
          petitioner actually acquired the Tri-Power reserves at a discount           
          rather than a premium as respondent contends.                               
                    Size of Tri-Power's NOL's                                         
               Respondent contends that the sheer enormity of Tri-Power's             
          NOL's in comparison to the value of its assets and their income-            
          producing potential indicates the primacy of tax motivations.               
          Respondent stresses the fact that by the end of 1993, petitioners           
          used almost $55 million of the Tri-Power NOL's but had yet to               
          recoup their $9.75 million investment through the cash-flow of              
          the Tri-Power properties.  Respondent further emphasizes that, as           
          a result of the NOL carryforwards in issue, petitioner paid no              
          regular Federal income tax during the period 1987 to 1993.                  





Page:  Previous  53  54  55  56  57  58  59  60  61  62  63  64  65  66  67  68  69  70  71  72  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011