Plains Petroleum Company and Subsidiaries - Page 54




                                       - 54 -                                         

               Another important factor is the testimony of the acquiring             
          corporation's top management.  See Capri, Inc. v. Commissioner,             
          65 T.C. at 179; D'Arcy-MacManus & Masius, Inc. v. Commissioner,             
          supra at 450.  Mr. Jackson, petitioner's CEO, Mr. Billings,                 
          petitioner's COO, and Mr. Reed, petitioner's vice president of              
          finance, all testified that petitioner paid nothing for Tri-                
          Power's NOL's.  Mr. Jackson and Mr. Wagner, petitioner's land               
          manager, also testified that they supported the acquisition of              
          Tri-Power because it satisfied all of petitioner's predefined               
          acquisition limitations.  Additionally, Harry S. Welch, a member            
          of petitioner's board, testified that the board was primarily               
          concerned with the acquisition of reserves and that the NOL's               
          were presented as a matter of secondary importance.  The                    
          foregoing individuals were intimately involved in the decision to           
          acquire Tri-Power.  Their testimony was credible.  In conjunction           
          with other corroborating evidence contained in the record, their            
          testimony is an important factor supporting our conclusion that             
          business considerations were the principal purpose for the                  
          acquisition of Tri-Power.                                                   
               The dropdown, which, as we have found supra, was an integral           
          part of petitioner's plan to acquire Tri-Power, facilitated                 
          petitioner's preexisting plan to adopt a holding company                    
          structure.  We recognize, as respondent so vigorously argues,               
          that the dropdown also enabled petitioner to use the Tri-Power              





Page:  Previous  44  45  46  47  48  49  50  51  52  53  54  55  56  57  58  59  60  61  62  63  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011