Estate of Richard R. Simplot - Page 61




                                       - 61 -                                         

          Class A Value at 6% Premium                                                 
          Equity value of Simplot (Q)                    $830,000,000.00              
          Premium for class A voting shares                           6%              
          Aggregate premium for class A shares (P)         49,800,000.00              
          Number of class A shares (A)        76.445                                  
          Number of class B shares (B)   141,288.584                                  
          Total number of shares  (T)    141,365.029                                  
          Economic value per share (E) = Q/T                    5,871.32              
          Class A premium per share = P/A                     651,448.75              
          Value per class A share before discounts           1657,320.08              
          Discounts for minority, lack of                                             
          marketability, and right of first                                           
          refusal (class A)                                                           
          (1 - 0.15) x (1 - 0.35) = .5525 = 45% (rounded) discount                    
          (1 - 0.15) x (1 - 0.40) = .51 = 49% discount                                
          Per share value of decedent's class A shares:                               
          After 45% discount                               361,526.04                 
          After 49% discount                               335,233.24                 
          Total value (rounded) of decedent's 18 class A                              
          shares:                                                                     
          After 45% discount                                6,507,469                 
          After 49% discount                                6,034,198                 
               1  We note that mathematically Mr. Matthews' calculation is off by 1 cent.
          Class B Value Using 6% Class A Premium                                      
          Economic value per share (E) = Q/T                   $5,871.32              
          Economic value of all class B shares (V) =                                  
          E x B                                          829,551,166.60               
          Less:  Aggregate premium for class A shares (P) (49,800,000.00)             
          Net value of all class B shares = V - P         779,751,166.60              
          Value per class B share before discounts =                                  
          (V - P)/B                                            5,518.85               
          Discount for lack of marketability (class B) = 35%                          
          Per share value of decedent's class B shares                                
          after 35% discount                                   3,587.26               
          Total value (rounded) of decedent's 3,942.048                               
          class B shares after 35% discount                  14,141,134               

Page:  Previous  51  52  53  54  55  56  57  58  59  60  61  62  63  64  65  66  67  68  69  70  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011