Florida Progress Corporation and Subsidiaries - Page 20




                                       - 20 -                                         

          obligation to make timely payments, the deposit ultimately was              
          refunded, and both the timing and method of refund were within              
          the control of the customer.  The customer could demand that the            
          taxpayer return the deposit payment by check or by setoff on the            
          customer’s next utility bill.                                               
               The Court held that the test for whether deposit payments              
          paid by customers constitute income when received by the taxpayer           
          depends upon the rights and obligations of the parties at the               
          time the payments are made.  See id. at 211.  The Court decided             
          that, because it was within the customer’s domain to prevent a              
          forfeiture of a deposit payment and because the customer rather             
          than the taxpayer determined how and when a deposit payment was             
          returned, the payments in question did not constitute income to             
          the taxpayer.  Where the time and manner of repayment is within             
          the control of the taxpayer, the payments would constitute                  
          income.  See Milenbach v. Commissioner, 106 T.C. 184, 197 (1996).           
               The return of overrecoveries of fuel and energy conservation           
          costs are not within the control of Florida Power.  The 6-month             
          recovery period, price setting, and true-up adjustment are all              
          set by the FPSC and FERC, which implemented the pricing schemes             
          to reduce the volatility of customers’ bills.  Florida Power is             
          required by regulatory law to overcollect for fuel and energy               
          conservation costs in certain months and to return those funds by           
          setoff on customers’ bills in the later months of the recovery              





Page:  Previous  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011