Carol M. Read, et al. - Page 39




                                       - 39 -                                         
               We shall now consider whether Ms. Read’s February 5, 1986              
          transfer of MMP stock qualifies as one of the three situations              
          described in Q&A-9.  The first situation in Q&A-9 describes a               
          transfer of property by the transferring spouse to a third party            
          on behalf of the nontransferring spouse that is required by a               
          divorce or separation instrument.  We hold that Ms. Read's                  
          transfer of her MMP stock to MMP was required by the divorce                
          judgment and fits within the first situation described in Q&A-9.            
          Although that transfer was required by the divorce judgment only            
          in the event that Mr. Read elected that Ms. Read transfer her MMP           
          stock to MMP, instead of to Mr. Read, once Mr. Read made that               
          election, which he did prior to Ms. Read’s transfer of her MMP              
          stock to MMP, that transfer was required by the divorce judgment.           
               We hold that Q&A-9 applies to Ms. Read’s February 5, 1986              
          transfer of MMP stock and that, pursuant to section 1041(a), no             
          gain shall be recognized by Ms. Read as a result of that trans-             
          fer.27  Mr. Read and MMP have indicated that if the Court were to           
          find, as we have, that section 1041 applies to Ms. Read’s trans-            
          fer of her MMP stock to MMP, the determinations in the respective           
          notices issued to Mr. Read and to MMP relating to that transfer             
          should be sustained.  Consequently, those determinations have               

               27We have considered all of the contentions and arguments of           
          Mr. Read and MMP that are not discussed herein and find them to             
          be without merit and/or irrelevant to our resolution of whether             
          Q&A-9 and sec. 1041 apply to Ms. Read’s transfer of her MMP stock           
          to MMP.                                                                     





Page:  Previous  29  30  31  32  33  34  35  36  37  38  39  40  41  42  43  44  45  46  47  48  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011