Ewens and Miller, Inc. - Page 15




                                       - 15 -                                         
                         a. Bakery Workers and Cash Payroll Workers                   
               Petitioner supplied the facility, equipment, and goods the             
          bakery workers and cash payroll workers used to perform their               
          jobs.  The bakery workers and cash payroll workers did not have             
          an investment in the goods or facilities.  This is indicative of            
          an employer-employee relationship.                                          
                         b. Route Distributors                                        
               Although some route distributors purchased petitioner’s                
          product for resale, rather than working on commission, they                 
          returned the product they did not sell to petitioner.  The route            
          distributors, however, owned their own vehicles.  On this record,           
          we conclude that the route distributors did have an investment in           
          facilities.                                                                 
                         c. Outside Sales Workers                                     
               The outside sales workers owned their own vehicles, and any            
          use of petitioner’s facilities was de minimis.  On this record,             
          we conclude that this factor does not weigh against treating the            
          outside sales workers as independent contractors.                           
                    3. Opportunity for Profit or Loss                                 
               The bakery workers and cash payroll workers were paid based            
          on the amount of product produced (which petitioner determined),            
          and the outside sales workers received a commission when they               
          sold petitioner’s product.  Some route distributors were paid a             
          commission for product they sold.  Others purchased petitioner’s            






Page:  Previous  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011