Physicians Insurance Company of Wisconsin, Inc. and Subsidiaries - Page 13




                                       - 13 -                                         
               [Petitioner’s] loss * * * reserves fall within the                     
               range established by Tillinghast of +10% of their best                 
               point estimate.[6]                                                     
               [Petitioner] is a relatively young company with                        
               adequate, but not extremely significant, amounts of                    
               historical results to assess the adequacy of loss                      
               reserves.                                                              
               [Petitioner] writes only medical malpractice liability                 
               policies.  This line is considered extremely volatile                  
               and may be subject to significant swings in experience                 
               between years.                                                         
               A write-down of the current year reserves would effect                 
               [sic] the Company’s trend in earnings.  Management’s                   
               incentive or bonus plans are not directly effected                     
               [sic] by current year earnings.                                        
               The Company is not publicly traded and there is                        
               currently no active market for the existing outstanding                
               shares.                                                                
               A portion of the reserve redundancy is maintained to                   
               offset potential tax exposure.                                         
               With regard to the last factor listed above, the Coopers               
          working paper noted that as a result of an audit of petitioner’s            
          1991 and 1992 tax returns, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) had           
          proposed various adjustments, including adjustments arising from            
          a determination that petitioner’s loss reserves were excessive.             
          The Coopers working paper notes that for petitioner’s taxable               
          years 1991 and 1992, these proposed tax adjustments totaled                 
          approximately $6.1 million.                                                 


               6 This observation is unsupported by the evidence, which               
          does not indicate that Tillinghast ever “established” or                    
          communicated the existence of any particular range around its               
          point estimates.                                                            





Page:  Previous  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011