Michael T. Caracci and Cindy W. Caracci, et al. - Page 38




                                       - 38 -                                         
          because accounting rules require the asset side and the liability           
          side of a company’s balance sheet to be equal.  His calculated              
          MVIC, which comprised long-term liabilities and owners’ equity,             
          did not include current liabilities.  Wilhoite reasoned that, by            
          adding the known current liabilities to the MVIC, he would                  
          complete the liability side of the balance sheet.  The asset                
          sheet would thus be an amount that equaled the liabilities so               
          computed.  He compared the inclusion of current liabilities as a            
          means of ascertaining value by showing that petitioners had done            
          essentially the same operation.  Their position was that the                
          companies’ value was equal to the total liabilities, both long-             
          term and short-term debt.  The difference between Wilhoite’s view           
          and that of petitioners is that Wilhoite concluded, on the basis            
          of his MVIC analysis, that the companies had some value, which              
          was expressed on the liabilities side as owners’ equity.                    
          Petitioners, however, maintained that there was no owners’ equity           
          and, hence, they did not include it in the balance sheet.   His             
          explanation stated:                                                         


               Basic accounting requires that the total asset value of                
               an entity (i.e., the “left-hand side” of the balance                   
               sheet) is equal to the sum of the total liabilities and                
               equity, or net asset value, of an entity (i.e., the                    
               “right-hand side” of the balance sheet).  * * *  [The                  
               Sta-Home for-profit entities] and the Caraccis reported                
               acquired all of the assets of the tax-exempt agencies                  
               by assuming all of the liabilities of the tax-exempt                   
               agencies.  Because the Caraccis assumed no equity value                
               existed, and because basic accounting requires that the                





Page:  Previous  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  35  36  37  38  39  40  41  42  43  44  45  46  47  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011