Jared R. and Naylene M. Nield - Page 17




                                       - 16 -                                         
          her in the parking lot at work (alleged tackling incident).6                
          Ms. Nield did not mention any such alleged incident in her State            
          claim, her complaint, or her deposition.  That was because,                 
          according to Ms. Nield, she was afraid of her supervisor, and she           
          did not mention the alleged tackling incident until an alleged              
          arbitration of her claims against Goer, which she contends took             
          place after her deposition, when Ms. Nield asserts her supervisor           
          was in jail, and which she contends led to the settlement agree-            
          ment.  Ms. Nield’s explanation about why she did not mention the            
          alleged tackling incident in her State claim, her complaint, or             
          her deposition is belied by the fact that Ms. Nield showed no               
          fear of her supervisor in advancing her various claims against              
          him and Goer in her State claim, her complaint, and her deposi-             
          tion.                                                                       

               A further illustration of Ms. Nield’s testimony that we find           
          to be questionable is her testimony that her complaint, which she           
          testified her attorney drafted on the basis of written informa-             
          tion that she provided to him, did not allege any personal                  
          physical injuries because she did not have the opportunity to               
          review the complaint before it was filed.  We find Ms. Nield’s              

               6Unlike her claim that she suffered bruising as a result of            
          the alleged elbowing incident, Ms. Nield did not claim at the               
          trial in this case, and the instant record does not establish,              
          that the alleged tackling incident caused her any personal                  
          physical injuries.  Moreover, the record establishes that Ms.               
          Nield did not seek medical treatment for any alleged bruising               
          from the alleged tackling incident.                                         





Page:  Previous  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011