Patricia Barranco - Page 18




                                       - 18 -                                         
          the $49,881 of adjusted gross income reported on the 1988 joint             
          return, the remaining $23,881 would have had to cover all the               
          other expenditures the Barrancos made that year:  Basic living              
          expenses not covered by the monthly stipend (e.g., mortgage                 
          payments, insurance, and taxes); tuition, room, and board                   
          expenses associated with two of their children’s college                    
          attendance (one of whom was at a private university); the                   
          $8,000–$10,000 wedding expenses for one of their daughters; a               
          Ford Probe for their son; and all the other items that allowed              
          the Barrancos to “live well”, as petitioner states on brief.   We           
          are unpersuaded that a reasonably prudent person in petitioner’s            
          position would have thought that the $49,881 of gross income                
          reported on the Barrancos’ joint return was sufficient to cover             
          all these expenditures.  The record does not suggest that the               
          Barrancos had available to them resources other than the omitted            
          income to support their lifestyle.                                          
               On brief, petitioner contends that the Barrancos’ lifestyle            
          was not lavish or unusual, but it was simply the “lifestyle of a            
          hard-working orthopedic surgeon’s family.”  In support of this              
          contention, petitioner states on brief that “orthopedic surgeons            
          generally do have very good incomes”.  Therein lies the rub.                
          Although the Barrancos were enjoying the lifestyle of a “hard-              
          working orthopedic surgeon’s family” during the years at issue,             
          Dr. Barranco and petitioner were reporting much less than the               






Page:  Previous  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011