James Benson Dunham and Melanie A. Dunham - Page 8

                                        - 8 -                                         
          warning given at the section 6330 hearing and the warning given             
          by the Court, petitioners did not abandon their frivolous                   
          arguments but authorized Mr. Jewett to continue to assert them.             
               Petitioners should be treated the same as other taxpayers              
          similarly situated.  As we stated in Brodman v. Commissioner,               
          supra:  “The taxpayers who continue to pursue those claims are              
          not entitled to a free ride.”  As a result, we hold that a                  
          penalty of $5,000 against petitioners should be awarded to the              
          United States pursuant to section 6673(a)(1).                               
               Moreover, we are concerned by the representation of Mr.                
          Jewett, an experienced attorney, in petitioners’ pursuit of these           
          frivolous claims.  All of Mr. Jewett’s arguments on behalf of               
          petitioners had been rejected by the Court in numerous cases.               
               Although, as in Brodman, we have decided not to impose a               
          penalty against Mr. Jewett under section 6673(a)(2),4 he is                 

               3(...continued)                                                        
                    maintained by the taxpayer primarily for delay,                   
                         (B) the taxpayer’s position in such proceeding is            
                    frivolous or groundless, or                                       
                         (C) the taxpayer unreasonably failed to pursue               
                    available administrative remedies,                                
               the Tax Court, in its decision, may require the taxpayer to            
               pay to the United States a penalty not in excess of $25,000.           
               4  Sec. 6673(a)(2) provides, in part:                                  
                              (2) Counsel’s liability for                             
                         excessive costs.--Whenever it appears to                     
                                                              (continued...)          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011