Merrill Lynch & Co., Inc. & Subsidiaries - Page 68




                                       - 68 -                                         
          of the cross-chain sale, Inspiration had not yet completed its              
          due diligence, contractually committed itself to buy the stock of           
          ML Leasing, or finalized its financing arrangements.  Moreover,             
          on the date of the cross-chain sale, the board of directors of              
          Merrill Parent had not yet authorized the sale of ML Leasing’s              
          stock, and Inspiration had not yet approved the purchase.  The              
          existence of these uncertainties according to petitioner                    
          precludes any finding that the cross-chain sale was part of a               
          firm and fixed plan to terminate ML Leasing’s actual and                    
          constructive ownership of Merlease.  We disagree.                           
               Whether a redemption and later sale are integrated steps in            
          a firm and fixed plan is a factual determination that necessarily           
          focuses on the actions of the redeemed shareholder and the                  
          redeeming corporation.  See Roebling v. Commissioner, supra;                
          Niedermeyer v. Commissioner, 62 T.C. 280 (1974).  If the actions            
          of the redeemed shareholder and the redeeming corporation                   
          evidence a firm and fixed plan to participate in two or more                
          related transactions that, individually or collectively, qualify            
          as a redemption under section 302(b), then the redemption                   
          executed pursuant to the plan will qualify as a sale or exchange            
          under section 302(a).  Niedermeyer v. Commissioner, supra.                  
               After examining the actions of the redeemed shareholder (ML            
          Leasing), the redeeming corporation (ML Asset Management), and              
          Merrill Parent, we are convinced that the deemed redemption under           






Page:  Previous  58  59  60  61  62  63  64  65  66  67  68  69  70  71  72  73  74  75  76  77  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011