Wells Fargo & Company (f.k.a. Norwest Corporation) and Subsidiaries - Page 48




                                                - 48 -                                                  
            the alternative, respondent argues that, if the method used                                 
            calculates an accrued liability independently of the fund assets,                           
            the unfunded accrued liability must be amortized over the remaining                         
            lives of the active employees.                                                              
                  We believe that use of the aggregate cost method to compute                           
            the reserve is not appropriate because that method will not permit                          
            full funding of the reserve with respect to a retired employee at                           
            retirement of that employee.  Further, we agree with petitioners                            
            that the accrued liability should be computed independently of the                          
            plan assets.  Indeed, there are circumstances under which the                               
            reserve could become overfunded and yet additional amounts could be                         
            added to the reserve using the aggregate cost method.21  We have no                         
            doubt that, in such an event, the Commissioner would require the                            
            use of another method that directly calculates an accrued liability                         
            independently of the plan assets.  Additionally, we have held that                          
            section 419A(c)(2) does not require the amortization of the accrued                         
            liability.                                                                                  
                  Section 419A(c)(2) requires that the reserve funded over the                          
            lives of the covered employees be “actuarially determined on a                              
            level basis”.  Thus, assets necessary to satisfy the employer’s                             

                  21    We note that use of the aggregate cost method is not                            
            permitted in computing the full-funding limit for pensions under                            
            sec. 412. Sec. 412(c)(7) defines the term “full-funding limitation”                         
            for purposes of sec. 412(c)(6) as the excess of the accrued                                 
            liability (including normal cost) under the plan, over the value of                         
            the plan’s assets.  The accrued liability is determined under the                           
            entry age normal cost method if the accrued liability cannot be                             
            directly calculated under the funding method used for the plan.                             




Page:  Previous  35  36  37  38  39  40  41  42  43  44  45  46  47  48  49  50  51  52  53  54  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011