Eric B. Benson, et al. - Page 58

                                       - 58 -                                         
          constituted constructive dividends to Burton in the year of                 
          transfer.                                                                   
               2.  ERG-Recreation Fund Account                                        
               Respondent submitted copies of canceled checks and bank                
          statements for the ERG-Recreation fund account.  Petitioners                
          conceded that many of the ERG-Recreation fund account items                 
          constituted constructive dividends to Burton.  See appendix, par.           
          7.  Melody Carter, ERG’s administrative assistant, testified that           
          this account was funded with moneys that ERG received “from                 
          recycling cans, recycling cardboard, refunds”, etc.  She stated:            
          “I’ll apply for the refund; the refund will go into that fund.”             
          She also testified that this account was used to “purchase                  
          baseball tickets, to purchase Christmas parties, company picnic,            
          weight room equipment, things of that nature.”53                            
               Respondent demonstrated that Burton was the sole signatory             
          for this account and withdrew funds from this account.  In                  
          addition to the canceled checks proffered by respondent and                 
          Burton’s concessions, the Court notes that the Bensons failed to            
          provide evidence that any specific amounts withdrawn were used              
          for ERG’s business purposes.  In fact, the checks at issue                  
          provide a contrary inference that the ERG-Recreation fund was               


               53Burton testified that at least one ERG Christmas party was           
          not paid from this account but was instead charged to a corporate           
          credit card.  See discussion infra.  There is no indication that            
          funds from this account were used to pay this bill.                         





Page:  Previous  48  49  50  51  52  53  54  55  56  57  58  59  60  61  62  63  64  65  66  67  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011