FPL Group, Inc. & Subsidiaries - Page 121

                                               - 200 -                                                  
            plant facility.’”  Id. at 653-654 (quoting S. Rept. 91-552, at                              
            235 (1969), 1969-3 C.B. 423, 572, and citing similar language in                            
            H. Rept. 91-413 (Part 1), at 187, 1969-3 C.B. 200, 317).  The                               
            refinery’s operation did not depend on the alkylation unit, as                              
            demonstrated by its operation for several years before the                                  
            construction of the alkylation unit.  Id. at 654.  The Court held                           
            that the alkylation unit itself, not the refinery as a whole, was                           
            the “plant facility” under section 49(b)(3) of the 1969 Code.                               
            Id.                                                                                         
                  Like the alkylation unit in OKC Corp. v. Commissioner,                                
            supra, petitioner’s transformers and other equipment at issue are                           
            distinct from the original substation construction.  The                                    
            substations were placed in service and in operation before the                              
            installation of the items at issue.133  For example, the Alva                               

                  133 See appendix A, which provides the dates that petitioner                          
            approved the ER for each of the items at issue.  Each substation                            
            and the date that it was placed in service or scheduled to be                               
            completed is as follows:                                                                    
                   Substation                                  Date                                     
                  Alva                          Sept. 1980                                              
                  Babcock                       May 1985                                                
                  Cedar                         June 1981                                               
                  Court                         May 1981                                                
                  Crystal                       Sometime between 1970 and 1972                          
                  Deltona                       July 1984                                               
                  Dumfoundling                  Nov. 1982                                               
                  Golden Gate                   Dec. 1983                                               
                  Hollybrook                    1988                                                    
                  Lakeview                      Mar. 1982                                               
                  Lewis                         May 1972                                                
                                                                          (continued...)                




Page:  Previous  190  191  192  193  194  195  196  197  198  199  200  201  202  203  204  205  206  207  208  209  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011