Barbara A. Owen - Page 36

                                       - 36 -                                         
               The problem with petitioner’s attempt to recover her                   
          allocable portion of the general group’s fees and costs is that             
          the information provided does not enable us to fully evaluate the           
          reasonableness of the group fees or the reasonableness of the               
          allocation.  The composition of the general group of Hoyt                   
          investors varied from month to month as clients chose to dismiss            
          their claims or became widowed or divorced and sought relief only           
          under section 6015(c).  Because the billing records for both                
          petitioner’s and the general group’s accounts lack detailed                 
          information regarding the number of Hoyt investor clients who               
          participated in the fee arrangement in each of the relevant                 
          months, it is impossible to verify that the generic monthly                 
          charges for group fees that appear on the records for                       
          petitioner’s individual account are reasonable and were                     
          reasonably allocated among petitioner and the other Hoyt                    
          investors clients.23                                                        


               22(...continued)                                                       
          those 15 hours, we assume that they were billed at the highest              
          hourly rate allowed.  Further, we do not add any charges for the            
          15 hours to the total costs and fees incurred by the general                
          group of Hoyt investors in computing petitioner’s share of that             
          group’s fees and costs because we lack any information about the            
          15 hours of work performed.                                                 
               23Had petitioner produced documentation for each month that            
          showed the number of clients who shared the fees, such as a                 
          spreadsheet similar to that produced for the January 2004 fee               
          allocation, we could have properly determined whether the amount            
          of costs petitioner claims was reasonable.                                  





Page:  Previous  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  35  36  37  38  39  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011