PATENT INTERFERENCES NO. 102,922 & 103,088 DUMAS V. GILL - Page 11




          Interference No. 102,922                                                    
          Interference No. 103,088                                                    


                                         IV.                                          
          Item 6: Gill motion to suppress evidence                                    
               Pursuant to 37 CFR § 1.656(h), Gill filed a motion to                  
          suppress (Paper No. 92 in '922 and No. 78 in '088).  The                    
          motion stands opposed (Paper No. 94 in '922 and No. 86 in                   
          '088).  A reply was filed (Paper No. 96 in '922 and No. 89 in               
          '088).                                                                      
               In the motion, Gill requested that Dumas Exhibits, DX 4-               
          6, 17-20, and 22, the data in DX 7 and 9, and the related                   
          testimony                                                                   
          including the testimony of Mr. Techentin relating to the AKD                
          formulation be stricken or denied consideration.                            
               More specifically, Gill urges that (1) DX 4-6 and 17-20                
          should not be considered because they do not comply with the                
          best evidence rule; (2) the sizing data of DX 7 and 9 and                   
          related testimony should be stricken because of (a)                         
          questionable reliability, (b) hearsay and because (c) the                   
          original data on which the summary data was based was                       
          destroyed under circumstances suggesting bad faith; (3) DX 22               
          should be stricken because it is incomplete and irrelevant;                 
          and (4) the testimony of Mr. Techentin relating to the AKD                  
                                         11                                           





Page:  Previous  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007