Appeal No. 97-2999 Page 6
Application No. 08/338,714
includes both the socket 30 and the clamp 28. The
specification also clearly describes that the male ball 32 is
formed of a material that is "harder" than the socket 30. In
our opinion, claim 33, when read in light of the
specification, is definite since the scope of the invention
sought to be patented can be determined from the language of
the claim with a reasonable degree of certainty. Furthermore,
while the examiner is correct that the language of claim 33 is
broad enough to read on the male ball being formed of a
material "harder" than the clamp, the mere breadth of the
claim does not in and of itself make the claim indefinite.
Claims 36 through 40
We do not agree with the examiner that claim 36 is
indefinite. When considering claim 36 as a whole, it is clear
to us that claim 36 is reciting the combination of a base, a
mount structure, a tool and at least two links. We reach this
conclusion based upon claim 36 reciting (1) "A structure . . .
comprising: a mount structure mounted to a base; a tool
mounted at a location remote from said base," and (2) that the
at least two links connect "said tool to said base." While we
Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 Next
Last modified: November 3, 2007