Ex parte GHIONE et al. - Page 16


            Appeal No. 1995-3257                                                      
            Application 08/056,382                                                    



            and we cannot find it.  Furthermore, the claims require a                 
            "pharmaceutically acceptable topical carrier".  Examiner                  
            takes the position that this is met by the references'                    
            teaching of a buffer.  In order to make that conclusion,                  
            examiner would have to show that they are identical.  The                 
            mere argument that the "buffers ... are deemed to meet                    
            the limitations of 'pharmaceutically acceptable topical                   
            carrier'" does not satisfy examiner's burden of showing                   
            identity in support of a rejection for anticipation under                 
            ' 102(b).  The rejection is reversed.                                     
                                      REVERSED                                        




            WILLIAM F. SMITH                         )                                
            Administrative Patent Judge              )                                
                           )                                                          
                           )                                                          
                           )                                                          
                         ) BOARD OF                                                   
            PATENT                                                                    
            JOAN ELLIS                               )     APPEALS                    
            Administrative Patent Judge              )       AND                      
                                                     )  INTERFERENCES                 
                           )                                                          
                           )                                                          
                           )                                                          
            HUBERT C. LORIN                          )                                
            Administrative Patent Judge              )                                
                                                                                     


                         16                                                           




Page:  Previous  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007