Ex parte ROSE et al. - Page 6




             Appeal No. 1995-4867                                                                                      
             Application 07/993,482                                                                                    


             appeal.  Assuming this prior art suggests combining the disparate elements in the manner                  
             required by claim 31 on appeal, we conclude that the relied upon references do not                        
             suggest the requisite reasonable expectation of success.                                                  
                    For example, the examiner's rejection is premised upon modification of the “vectors                
             of Crowl and Maniatis.”  (examiner's answer, page 5).  While Crowl does describe vectors                  
             useful for expressing human immune interferons, Crowl does not describe the secretion of                  
             the interferon from the host cells into the culture medium.  Maniatis does discuss the                    
             secretion of foreign genes expressed in E. coli at page 433 as follows:                                   
                           Vectors that allow fusion of foreign genes to DNA encoding a signal                         
                    sequence may be useful for exporting proteins out of the cytoplasm,                                
                    especially if the signal peptide is cleaved during export of the protein.                          
                    Export of the proteins may assist in subsequent purification and may serve                         
                    to isolate them from cytoplasmic proteases.  However, the factors that                             
                    determine whether a given protein will be secreted when it is fused with a                         
                    particular leader peptide have not been elucidated.                                                
             Secretion of foreign proteins expressed in host cells is discussed in Chang at page 6,                    
             lines 15-21 as follows:                                                                                   
                           “Secretion” refers to transport through the cytoplasmic membrane.                           
                    Whether or not the protein appears in the medium is dependent on the                               
                    presence or absence of an outer membrane: in the presence of outer                                 
                    membrane the secreted protein will be found in the periplasm, in the                               
                    absence of outer membrane it will be in the medium.                                                
             As set forth in the paragraph bridging pages 2-3 of Chang, E. coli is a gram-negative                     
             bacteria where the cytoplasmic membrane is encased in an outer cell membrane wall.                        


                                                          6                                                            





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007