Ex parte KULKARNI - Page 6




          Appeal No. 96-0862                                                          
          Application 08/055,971                                                      


               Furthermore, each independent claim specifically recites               
          that the micro-code vectors to be output from the output means              
          are selected “without retrieving stored addresses in said                   
          branch condition micro-vectors” [claim 12 omits “branch”].                  
          This limitation permits the wasting of fewer clock cycles over              
          the prior art.  Yet, the examiner never satisfactorily                      
          explains how Keller suggests this limitation.                               
               While appellant points out many differences between the                
          instant claimed invention and the prior art mentioned in the                
          specification, as well as Keller, [see, for example, the                    
          supplemental reply brief, pages 2-5], concluding, at page 5,                
          that                                                                        
               [n]either Keller nor the prior art described in                        
                    the specification teach [sic, teaches] or                         
                    suggest [sic, suggests] a micro-code vector                       
                    address selection means comprising a pointer for                  
                    identifying a micro-vector to be output and a                     
                    plus one adder for incrementing an address                        
                    stored in the point [sic, pointer] on each clock                  
                    cycle such that the micro-code vector address                     
                    selection means selects a next sequentially                       
                    stored micro-code vector from the micro code                      
                    means after selecting branch condition vectors,                   
          the examiner’s response is merely to contend that the                       
          incrementing by one is “well-known in the art” [second                      
          supplemental answer, page 3] and that the selection of a                    
                                         -6-                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007