Ex parte CHAPMAN - Page 6




          Appeal No. 96-4149                                                          
          Application 08/276,436                                                      


          movement of the bracket relative to its supporting structure                
          to provide a dampening effect "much like the effect of a                    
          spring, shock absorber, or the like" (specification, page 5)                
          for a given force.  Accordingly, we are left to speculate as                
          to just which combinations of brackets secured to supporting                
          structures by fasteners with clearance between a bracket                    
          aperture and a fastener would fall within the metes and bounds              
          of the claims and which would not.  Stated differently, while               
          any bracket and strap restraint arrangement wherein the                     
          bracket is secured to a supporting structure by a fastener                  
          extending through an aperture in the bracket with clearance                 
          would meet the broad structural and step requirements of the                
          appealed claims, it is not clear which of these restraint                   
          arrangements appellant intends to exclude through the use of                
          language such as "in such a manner that the bracket can                     
          undergo slight, controlled, movement with relation to the                   
          structure under conditions of stress to the structure" (claim               
          1) and "in such manner that the structure may move a                        
          controlled amount with relation to the position of the bracket              
          in a limited, and repeated manner" (claim 4).                               


                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007