MORRISON et al. V. MANNHEIMER et al. - Page 52




          Interference No. 103,197                                                      


          design shown in MX 50, dated October 6, 1988, which employs a                 
          solid screw helix and two short hypodermic needles each having                
          a single bend therein and containing an optical fiber.   As76                    
          explained infra, probe designs employing straight hypodermic                  
          needles containing optical fibers were not conceived until the                
          fall of 1989.  See, e.g., MX 13, date stamped October 3, 1989,                
          which shows a probe body 6 supporting a solid corkscrew needle                
          9 and an axially disposed straight hypodermic needle 10 which                 
          contains an optical fiber 1, which is the needle design that                  
          Buschmann concedes was actually reduced to practice on                        
          September 19, 1989.   No attempt was ever made to assemble a77                                                        
          probe employing two straight hypodermic needles, as used in                   
          the February tests.  Nor is such an arrangement disclosed in                  
          Morrison's involved application.                                              
               For the foregoing reasons, we conclude that the February                 
          1988 test apparatus, rather than being envisioned as an                       
          embodiment of a complete and operative probe as it would be                   
          thereafter applied in practice, instead was simply designed to                
          determine the feasibility of using hypodermic needles                         

            T. Johnson, MR 32, ¶ 26.76                                                                       
            B.Br. 43, ¶ 112.77                                                                       
                                        - 49 -                                          





Page:  Previous  45  46  47  48  49  50  51  52  53  54  55  56  57  58  59  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007