MORRISON et al. V. MANNHEIMER et al. - Page 82




          Interference No. 103,197                                                      


          emphasis) inaccurately characterizes Hochberg,  which uses130                            
          both of its optical fibers (30 and 32) to measure pH.                         
          Hochberg uses wires 22 and 24 to measure EKG, i.e., the fetal                 
          pulse rate.                                                                   
               Assuming for the sake of argument that Ted Johnson's                     
          testimony about using the March 15, 1988, design to measure                   
          oxygen saturation in the manner of the "2nd Generation probe"                 
          is credible, the March 15, 1988, design nevertheless fails as                 
          evidence of conception because it employs an optical fiber to                 
          deliver light to the tissue site, which was an inoperative                    
          technique at that time for the reasons given above in                         
          connection  with the November 1987 design and the February                    
          1988 test apparatus.                                                          
               7.  Diligence                                                            
               As Morrison has failed to prove conception prior to                      
          Buschmann's March 24, 1988, benefit date, it is not necessary                 
          to consider whether Morrison was diligent during the period                   
          running from just before that date up to September 19, 1989,                  
          the date of his actual reduction to practice.  Nevertheless,                  
          we have considered this in the interest of completeness.                      

            Mannheimer Exhibit 44.130                                                                      
                                        - 79 -                                          





Page:  Previous  75  76  77  78  79  80  81  82  83  84  85  86  87  88  89  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007