MORRISON et al. V. MANNHEIMER et al. - Page 81




          Interference No. 103,197                                                      


          saturation in the manner of the "2nd  Generation" probe, which                
          employed a total of four optical fibers, three in a first                     
          hypodermic needle, of which two are used to measure pH and the                
          third is used to measure oxygen saturation in cooperation with                
          a fourth fiber contained in a second hypodermic needle.  The                  
          sketches of the March 15, 1988, design clearly show a total of                
          two optical fibers, of which MX 47 indicates that the "FIBER                  
          IN CORKSCREW CAN BE FOR PH" and the "FIBER ON HUB SURFACE CAN                 
          DETECT PULSE."   As a result, we are not persuaded that the128                                                             
          March 15, 1987, probe design was intended to be used to                       
          measure oxygen saturation by pulse oximetry.  It is possible                  
          that this design instead represents a probe for measuring pH                  
          and pulse rate (i.e., heartbeat), albeit in a manner that is                  
          not apparent to us. Consequently, the March 15, 1988, design                  
          does not represent a conception.  We note in passing that                     
          Buschmann's contention  that "the drawings [of the March 15,129                                                    
          1988, design] refer to one optical fiber for pulse and another                
          optical fiber for pH (apparently similar to Hochberg)" (our                   



            Notation adjacent to bottom sketch on MX 47.128                                                                      
            B.Br. 21-22.129                                                                      
                                        - 78 -                                          





Page:  Previous  74  75  76  77  78  79  80  81  82  83  84  85  86  87  88  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007