MORRISON et al. V. MANNHEIMER et al. - Page 80




          Interference No. 103,197                                                      


               While I understood that this configuration (having two                   
               optical fibers arranged for placement below the fetal                    
               skin and spaced from each other) was for pulse oximetry,                 
               i.e., measuring fetal oxygen saturation, I also                          
               understood that one of the optical fibers could be used                  
               to measure the pH, in addition to pulse oximetry, along                  
               the lines of the Second [G]eneration design shown in                     
               Exhibit 42. 126                                                          
          Johnson's explanation of the March 15, 1988, design is                        
          unconvincing for several reasons.  First, when he was asked                   
          during cross-examination to explain how this design would                     
          monitor oxygen saturation, he replied that he did not know.  127              
          Second,  none of the documents disclosing the March 15, 1988,                 
          design employ any of the language used in the November 24,                    
          1987, exhibit (MX 42) to indicate that oxygen saturation is to                
          be measured, i.e., the language "Oximeter" (pp. 2, 4),                        
          "Provides % O  saturation" (p. 2), and "oximeter fiber"                       
                       2                                                                
          (bottom of p. 4).  Instead, the March 15, 1988, design                        
          documents employ the term "pH," which is clearly distinguished                
          from oximetry in the notations about the "2nd Generation"                     
          probe.  Third, the drawings of the March 15, 1988, design do                  
          not show enough optical fibers to measure pH and oxygen                       


            T. Johnson, MR 27-28, ¶ 18.126                                                                      
            T. Johnson, MR 576:14-16.127                                                                      
                                        - 77 -                                          





Page:  Previous  73  74  75  76  77  78  79  80  81  82  83  84  85  86  87  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007