RAPOPORT V. DEMENT et al. - Page 22




          Interference 102,760                                                        
          need of such treatment” (SRR, WIA, RI 2, p. 258; emphasis                   
          added), in support                                                          
          of his position.                                                            
               While this evidence indicates that neither Rosekind nor                
          Schwimmer contributed to Dement’s conception of a method for                
          treatment of sleep apnea comprising administration of a                     
          therapeutically effective amount of buspirone to a patient in               
          need of such treatment, Rapoport has not thereby shown that                 
          (1) Schwimmer did not contribute to the concept of a method                 
          for treating sleep apnea comprising administration of                       
          therapeutically effective amounts of azapirones other than                  
          buspirone to a patient in need of such treatment and did not                
          otherwise contribute to a patentable invention of Claims 1-13               
          of Application 07/695,325, or (2) Rosekind did not contribute               
          to a patentable invention of Claims 1-13 of Application                     
          07/695,325.   Rapoport has not established that Dement’s5                                                                
          conception of a method for treatment                                        
          of sleep apnea comprising administration of a therapeutically               
          effective amount of buspirone to a patient in need of such                  
          treatment itself constitutes a patentable invention, i.e. an                

              5    In other words, Rapoport has not shown that Claims 1-13           
          of Application 07/695,325 would be patentable to Dement without             
          the contributions of Schwimmer and Rosekind.                                
                                         22                                           





Page:  Previous  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007