Ex parte JOHNSTON et al. - Page 6




          Appeal No. 2000-0146                                       Page 6           
          Application No. 08/979,069                                                  


          re Mattison, 509 F.2d 563, 565, 184 USPQ 484, 486 (CCPA                     
          1975)).                                                                     


               Here, claims 20 and 21 specify in pertinent part the                   
          following limitations: "zooming from a first bounding                       
          rectangle for the selected block of text at a source location               
          to a second bounding rectangle for the selected block of text               
          at the destination location ...."  The specification describes              
          the zooming as follows.                                                     
               [T]he zoom starts with a bounding rectangle 100                        
               displayed near the source location.  Two or more                       
               rectangles are displayed on monitor 12 at a time,                      
               each successive rectangle more closely approaching                     
               the dimensions and final location of bounding                          
               rectangle 104.  Figure 4C attempts to illustrate                       
               this idea.  The dimensions of intervening rectangle                    
               106 differ slightly from those bounding rectangle                      
               100, just starting to approach those of bounding                       
               rectangle 104.  Similarly, the dimensions of                           
               intervening rectangle 108 differ from those of                         
               intervening rectangle 106, approaching more closely                    
               the dimensions of bounding rectangle 104.  The zooms                   
               ends with the display of bounding rectangle 104 near                   
               the destination location.                                              
          (Spec. at 14-15.)  Reading the claims in light of the                       
          specification, the limitations require that zooming begins                  
          with the display of a first bounding rectangle for a selected               
          block of text at a source location and ends with the display                







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007