Ex parte JOHNSTON et al. - Page 8




          Appeal No. 2000-0146                                       Page 8           
          Application No. 08/979,069                                                  


          rectangle for a selected block of text at a source location.                
          Specifically, “[s]haded area 8 in FIG. 3 shows one possible                 
          appearance of marked data and, for purposes of illustration of              
          the invention, represents a data source location.”  Id. at                  
          ll. 59-62.  The examiner does not show, however, that Peters’               
          data transfer operation ends with the display of a second                   
          bounding rectangle for the selected block of text at a                      
          destination location.  To the contrary, Figure 4 of the                     
          reference, which “is a representation of the two windows of                 
          FIG. 3 after completion of the transfer of data between those               
          two windows,” col. 3, ll. 49-51, shows no bounding rectangles               
          at all, let alone a second bounding rectangle for the selected              
          block of text at a destination location.                                    


               Because there is no showing that Peters’ data transfer                 
          operation ends with the display of a second bounding rectangle              
          for the selected block of text at a destination location, we                
          are not persuaded that the applied prior art discloses the                  
          limitations of  "zooming from a first bounding rectangle for                
          the selected block of text at a source location to a second                 
          bounding rectangle for the selected block of text at the                    







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007