Appeal No. 1998-2948 Application 08/400,861 Hochido, Yamamoto, Joshi, and Lee disclose an aluminum/rare earth metal alloy, with the rare earth element in the claimed proportion, for use as an interconnection conductor in integrated circuits, including as electrodes for thin film transistors in LCDs (Yamamoto), but do not discuss anodic oxidizing the interconnect/electrode film. Hochido and Lee disclose an aluminum/rare earth element alloy having beneficial properties, especially reduction of undesirable hillock formation, for use as an interconnection conductor in integrated circuits. While it can be reasoned that one of ordinary skill in the art would have been motivated to substitute the aluminum/rare earth element alloy of Hochido or Lee for the aluminum alloy in Kiyota to achieve the stated benefits, there is more specific motivation found in Joshi and Yamamoto. Joshi discloses that addition of elements with low solubility is an approach to achieve metallization with improved characteristics without deterioration in electrical conductivity, as compared to prior art alloys such as Al-Cu, and that rare earth elements have relatively low solubilities in aluminum, so an aluminum/rare earth element alloy would provide improvement over the prior - 9 -Page: Previous 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007